A Strong Offense
A Stronger Defense
Does the settlor’s grant of a broader power to a trustee necessarily, by implication, include the grant of the lesser power? Practitioners have often answered “yes” to this question when it comes to justify so-called ‘common law’ trust decanting. So, for example, if the settlor gave the trustee the discretionary authority to distribute the entirety of the corpus without regard to any standard, the argument is that the grant of that broad power would necessarily include the lesser power to decant.
In a different context, in an unpublished opinion in Leonard v. Maher (2014 Mass. App. Unpub. LEXIS 885) (Rule 1:28 decision), the Appeals Court of Massachusetts used similar logic to conclude that where the settlors, trustees, grantors and beneficiaries of a trust are the same people, the power to terminate a trust as trustee included the lesser right of the grantor to amend it.
Of course, it’s a different context with specific, unique facts, but we again see a court being persuaded by the argument that a lesser power is included within the grant of a broader power.